There comes a point when your business needs more than one person to do the task at hand. The decision to hire an employee is something business owners should think through, or it could eat up cash reserves if not budgeted properly. A common mistake business owners make is considering salary the total cost of hiring an employee, when the real cost is higher. Apart from salary, hiring costs include recruitment, onboarding, employee benefits, payroll taxes, compliance, training, equipment, office space, and ongoing payroll management.

Costs to Consider Before Hiring an Employee

Some people use a standard formula of 1.25x–1.4x base salary to estimate the cost of hiring an employee. However, such thumb rules can be misleading if you have employees in different provinces, pay scales, and industries, as provincial compliance costs vary significantly. A wide gap between estimated and actual hiring costs, or a wrong hire, can cost your business dearly. Hence, business owners should carefully structure their payroll and sync their employment budget with business cash flows. And for that, you need to understand the true cost of hiring an employee.

Recruitment Cost

Hiring an employee starts with recruitment costs, which vary based on the position youare trying to fill (entry-level, managerial, or executive), location (province/metro), industry specialization, and hiring method (internal HR or recruitment agencies). It includes costs for job board postings, recruitment agency commissions/employee referral program payouts, and interviewing.

2. Salary and Mandatory Employer Contributions

Next comes salary negotiation, which includes fixed and variable components (annual travel stipends, performance bonuses, and more). This cost is one of the highest and depends on the skill set, location, and post you are hiring for. Based on the base salary, mandatory deductions are determined:

  • The employer deducts Canada Pension Plan (CPP), which is 5.95% of the employee’s earnings between $3,500 and $74,600 in 2026, and 4% for salaries above $74,600 and up to $85,000. The employer contributes an equal amount and remits it to the CRA.
  • For Employment Insurance (EI), the employer deducts 1.63% of insurable earnings up to $68,900, with a maximum employer contribution of $1,572.30 per employee per year.

Every province has different employer health taxes (EHT) and workers’ compensation costs, adding to the employee cost. As we said before, the gap between taxes and benefits across provinces and industries can be vast, making the standard formula misleading. For instance, workers’ compensation premiums can range from $0.20/$100 to $14/$100, depending on the industry. You must also consider these provincial costs before hiring an employee, rather than relying on a standard formula.

Onboarding, Compliance and Administrative Costs

Once the salary structure is negotiated, it is time to onboard the employee, sign the contract, perform background checks, set up the payroll system, and create necessary accounts, all of which are covered under onboarding costs. Once on payroll, there is a recurring cost for administration and compliance to calculate benefits, work hours, performance bonuses, and accordingly remit CPP, EI, and income tax to the CRA, and issue T4 slips. Also budget for employment legislation, HR support, insurance, and supervision when calculating employment cost.

Equipment and Operating Costs

Employees need equipment and resources to perform their tasks. For instance, a SaaS company may need specialized computers, software licenses, servers, office furniture, mobile devices, professional memberships, or specialized equipment. They might need employees to obtain certain licenses and certifications, learn new software and artificial intelligence tools, and renew licenses to keep operations running. Construction companies may need specialized worker safety equipment, fire safety equipment, and cybersecurity tools. All these costs should also be considered before making a hiring decision. While it may not be directly linked to payroll, it is a necessary cost that depends on the workforce count.

Productivity Costs

While you equip the employee to perform the task, there is a learning curve before the employee delivers results, and that depends on the complexity of the role. It’s not just that particular employee’s productivity, but also the time of the senior member who is coaching or handing over the work to the new hire. This is an indirect cost and reduces productivity in the short term. It doesn’t appear as a line item in the income statement, and therefore doesn’t even appear in the budget, creating a gap between estimated and actual figures.

It is not just the learning curve, but paid leave (vacation, statutory holidays, sick leave, and other legislated leaves) that affects productivity levels. For a factory where daily output matters, these leaves add to the costs. The absence of one employee increases the workload of others, leading to overtime and temporary gig workers, all of which add to costs.

Optional Employee Benefits Cost to Improve Retention

So far, we only talked about statutory benefits, leaves, and taxes, which are mandatory for the business to stay compliant. But they are not enough to be competitive. Many companies compete for the right talent and skill set. Not every engineer can build a successful product or solve a defect. Finding and retaining the right talent comes at the cost of optional benefits like employer-sponsored health, vision, and dental coverage; a company pension; higher salaries; performance bonuses; and profit-sharing through stock options. You could also consider hybrid work environments, career development opportunities, and employee-sponsored courses.

Why incur it? Some employees stay for the benefits even if the salary is not as competitive. Considering the cost of hiring, onboarding, and training a new employee, and the risk of a wrong hire, employers could consider retaining the right talent by spending extra on optional benefits. It is better to ask employees to vote for the benefits they want to ensure the extra cost of optional benefits improves employee satisfaction, reduces churn, and builds a stronger workplace culture.

Tips To Reduce Employment Costs in Canada

Once you list all the costs on paper, you can design an organizational structure, pay scale, and consider options like outsourcing or hiring freelancers for certain jobs that are not time-sensitive. The CRA offers several tax credits for hiring employees for specific tasks, including the Scientific Research and Experimental Development tax rebates, apprenticeship hiring incentives, and student or co-operative education programs.

Contact Black and Gill LLP in Etobicoke to Help You with Hiring Budgets

Talk to a professional accountant to help you design a pay structure, set up a payroll system, and budget accurately for employee hiring. At Black and Gill LLP, our accountants and bookkeepers can provide services such as payroll and budgeting. To learn more about how Black and Gill LLP in West Toronto can provide you with the best accounting and bookkeeping services, contact us online or call us at 416-477-7681.